First Team Offense
LT: Josh Sills, LG: Kyle Bosch, C: Matt Jones, RG: Grant Lingafelter, RT: Colton McKivitz, QB: Will Greer, RB: Justin Crawford, WR: Jovon Durante, WR: David Sills, WR: Ricky Rogers, WR: Gary Jennings, FB: Elijah Wellman.
First Team Defense
DE: Adam Shuler, NT: Xavier Pegues, DE: Reese Donahue, CB: Elijah Battle, CB: Mike Daniels, Bandit: Toyous Avery, LB: David Long, MLB: Al-Rasheed Benton, LB: Hodari Christian, Spur: Marvin Gross, FS: Jovanni Stewart.
Second Team Offense
LT: Ja’HShaun Seider, LG: Chase Behrndt, C: Ray Raulerson, RG: Kelby Wickline, RT: Rob Dowdy, QB: Chris Chugunov, RB: Tevin Bush/Martell Pettaway, WR: Connor Watts, WR: Druw Bowen, WR: Dominique Maiden, WR: Alejandro Marenco.
Second Team Defense
DE: Ezekiel Rose, NT: Jaleel Fields, DE: Jon Lewis, CB: Jake Long, CB: Sean Mahone, Bandit: Derrek Pitts, LB: Logan Thimons, MLB: Brendan Ferns, LB: Adam Hensley, Spur: Shane Commodore, FS: Toyous Avery/Osman Kamara.
- A number of Mountaineers did not participate because of injuries, including at least three potential defensive starters (linebacker Xavier Preston, spur Kyzir White and free safety Dravon Askew-Henry) and three potential offensive starters (wide receiver Ka’Raun White, wide receiver Marcus Simms and offensive tackle Yodny Cajuste).