Grading The Mountaineers: OSU Report Card

Grading The Mountaineers: OSU Report Card

West Virginia got off to a strong start Saturday at Oklahoma State. It controlled most of the first 30 minutes and took a 31-14 lead into the lockerroom at halftime.

The second half was a different story, though, as the Mountaineer offense left opportunities on the field and their defense just couldn’t get stops, giving up scoring drives on five of OSU’s six second half possessions. The Cowboys came storming back for a 45-41 victory that ended the College Football Playoff dreams for the 8-2 Mountaineers.

Logan Holgorsen Dana Holgorsen and Jake Spavital look out over the field before the game

Let’s grade West Virginia’s effort in Stillwater.

Offensive Grade – C WVU posted 41 points and 553 yards in the contest, but in the end, that wasn’t enough. The Mountaineers left too many points on the field against an Oklahoma State offense capable of generating incredible numbers itself. This was a classic shootout, and West Virginia scored five touchdowns and two field goals. But it was stopped with no points twice inside the OSU 18, and that doesn’t count the last-gasp opportunity that ended at the 14 with an incompletion in the end zone as time expired. The Mountaineers also ran for 162 yards in the first half but just 27 in the second. WVU head coach Dana Holgorsen said it best after the tough loss – “We had a chance to close them out and we didn’t. Great teams close people out, and we didn’t do that.”

Defensive Grade – D West Virginia got stops and turnovers in the first half. A pair of interceptions and a fumble recovery, as well as forcing four OSU punts, had the Mountaineers sitting with a comfortable 17-point halftime lead. But as West Virginia’s offense began to sputter in the second half, its defense began to get torched. Of the 604 yards amassed by the Cowboys in the game, 396 came in the second half. OSU’s quarterback Taylor Cornelius hurt the Mountaineers as much with his feet as his arm. He ran for 86 yards in the second half and 106 in the game, while throwing for 338 yards in total. Other than a turnover on a muffed punt late in the third quarter, West Virginia’s defense managed just one other stop in the second half. The WVU offense could have help out its defensive brethren, but the Mountaineer defense did little to help itself.

Special teams – B- There were positives and negatives to West Virginia’s special teams’ effort. A partially blocked punt was the worst of the negatives, but it at least rolled for 26 yards, keeping it from being awful. The biggest positive was recovering an OSU muff when OK State’s Dillon Stoner tried to catch a bouncing punt. Josh Chandler recovered for WVU, but the Mountaineer offense couldn’t completely cash in the gift, settling for a field goal on a drive that started on the Cowboys’ 18.

Coaching – D When a team wins the turnover battle 4-1, it simply isn’t supposed to lose. Yet West Virginia managed to defy those odds despite being +3 in turnover margin. WVU’s defensive coaches couldn’t figure out anything to slow down the Cowboys in the second half, and the Mountaineers’ short yardage offense remains an issue. Twice Saturday it failed to convert when facing a yard or less to go. Then clinging to a 41-38 lead late, Dana Holgorsen’s decision to go for it on fourth-and-six was thwarted by a false start penalty on senior David Sills. Lack of focus by the player also has to be shouldered by the coaches.

Atmosphere – B- It was a near perfect afternoon weather-wise in Stillwater. The temperature at kickoff was 64, and while it dropped a good bit the course of the game, it remained a nice mid-November day. Despite the excellent fall weather in central Oklahoma, Boone Pickens Stadium had large swaths of empty seats. Oklahoma State students were on the front end of their Thanksgiving break, so their absence was understandable. Still, the 56,790-seat stadium was barely half full at the start, and 50 percent of those left at halftime. Those who departed missed a memorable comeback in OSU annals. When a fan base is used to 10+ win seasons, as the Cowboys have enjoyed in six of the previous eight years, a fall to .500 is met with apathy even on Senior Day.



Home forums Grading The Mountaineers: OSU Report Card

This topic contains 5 replies, has 5 voices, and was last updated by Butlereer Butlereer .

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
  • #74769

    Grading The Mountaineers: OSU Report Card West Virginia got off to a strong start Saturday at Oklahoma State. It controlled most of the first 30 minut
    [See the full post at: Grading The Mountaineers: OSU Report Card]


    Summed up nicely, and well graded.

    The second half told the story, just as it did in Lubbock–and carried through the next two games…which is concerning, needless to say. Absolutely pitiful, and nearly 100% on the coaches.

    Another punch right in the gut for the faithful, particularly in a season when things were aligned just right–or so we thought. This just cuts right to the quick.


    I only disagree on the player focus, any senior doesn’t need his coach to tell him the snap count, that’s on Sills but that one play didn’t lose the game. I think this may have exposed Sills a little as he didn’t do a good job of fighting off the tight coverage, that will be noticed by pro scouts as you don’t get to run free much in the NFL. Personally though I would have graded the coaches a D- for other things that they didn’t do. As was said in the movie Remember the Titans, “he’s on to your game coach” and we didn’t adjust.


    Never stopped the zone read. Surely Gibby knows that play. Pat White would run for 300 on WV’s current defense.


    Sills was covered like a blanket all game. Partly due to good coverage. Partly because he wasn’t getting calls for a guy mugging him on nearly every play. Late in the game he had to push his defender off–which was not only booed by the home fans, but should have been called, quite honestly–but, as pointed out by the TV crew, something he finally had to do to break away from a defender that, up to that point should have been called continuously for interference.

    Maybe at the next level that’s different, but in the college game–and in today’s game, that wasn’t called on almost every play with sills. AJ Green, I believe, was assigned to him on nearly every play as the OSU mugger.


    I may have given the Offensive grade a little higher C+ / B- . 553 yds and 41 pts should be enough to win the game. But we just didn’t have the punch to get it done. Poor time management in the last possession. We should have called TO earlier. Could have had another play or two.

    Sills was mugged on almost every play. Most would have been called in the NFL by any decent ref. But we are in the B12 and playing away. Makes a huge difference. Could have used Wesco and Haskins a little more. Why we ever put Bush in as the RB is beyond me.

    Defense at a D is a liberal grade. 1st half was good. Forced TO’s. Contained Cornelius. Boys up front did a great job. 2nd half it looked like Gibby changed the game plan. Changed it to hand OSU the game. Cornelius ran for 100+ yds. The holes were sooooooo gaping wide that I could run for 100. IMO this game was COMPLETELY on Gibby. We just gave them the game. Couldn’t stop anything in the 2nd. NOTHING>… 2nd half grade has to be no better than F- .

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Home forums Grading The Mountaineers: OSU Report Card