Phantom Pass Interference Haunts WVU Defense

Phantom Pass Interference Haunts WVU Defense

MORGANTOWN, W.Va. – There’s no excusing portions of West Virginia’s defensive play.

The Mountaineers had misfits, missed tackles and missed assignments. They also had a handful of missed opportunities.

But the thing that was the most missed was a pass interference call that switched momentum back to Oklahoma State and marked the beginning of the end. With No. 22 West Virginia on the rally – having used a blocked punt and an interception return for a score to get within 30-24 – the defense forced the Cowboys into a third and 11 from midfield early in the fourth quarter.

OSU quarterback Mason Rudolph lofted an underthrown ball down the sideline to receiver Chris Lacy. The wideout tried to spin back for the ball and drew minimal contact from WVU cornerback Hakeem Bailey. The official closest to the play didn’t pull the flag. But one farther up the field called Bailey for pass interference. It was, make no mistake, a poor call and nothing more than phantom interference.

But that ghost was real enough in this instance, and the resulting call haunted the Mountaineers for the remainder of the game. Instead of taking possession with waves of momentum, WVU was slapped with the 15-yard penalty, giving Oklahoma State a fresh set of downs at the 34-yard line. The Cowboys scored seven plays later, zapping the vigor out of the comeback in extending the edge to 37-24.

“It was a one-possession game at that point,” defensive coordinator Tony Gibson said. “Then we get them to third down and another PI call. That was big. That shifts momentum of the game. We had everything going our way. We have to learn to play the next play. Then we get them to third and goal and we got two guys to the ball carrier and we missed tackles.”

Whatever had built to that point crumbled from there, OSU scoring on its next two possessions in finishing the game with three consecutive touchdowns before simply running out the clock in the 50-39 decision. There remains a lingering impression that the call looms as far bigger than simply the 15 yards itself. There are precious few opportunities to get Oklahoma State’s offense off the field, and a third and 11 is as good as it gets. Maybe West Virginia’s offense manages to score, maybe it doesn’t. But the defense sure as heck should have been allowed to give it a chance.

Still, there are issues. West Virginia allowed a season-high 50 points, with part of that the residue of playing 90 snaps against arguably the best offense in the nation. It was hurt by a sound passing attack and couldn’t corral the run enough to offset that excellence, giving up 246 yards on the ground – including 142 to freshman J,D. King after Justice Hill was removed from the game early because of a neck injury.

“It’s difficult, especially against an offense as explosive as them,” Gibson said. “It was tough. They made plays; give them credit. We didn’t, and lost the game. They hit fast and scored. We weren’t good on first down. When we were good, they wouldn’t go tempo and we settled down and made some plays in the third quarter. We got some momentum in the third and couldn’t capitalize on it. But it was wasn’t enough.”

Yet the Mountaineers also forced and recovered three fumbles to go with the interception, had the pick six score and limited OSU to one touchdown on seven possessions spanning the second and third quarters. Linebacker David Long played like a man possessed with a whopping seven tackles for loss, and the unit held up effectively on the back end until the cumulative effect of the sheer amount of plays took hold.

“It looks like we need to scrap everything we do and try to figure something else out,” Gibson said. “We gotta get guys healthy and guys playing. It’s not very hard what we do. Obviously everybody else has figured it out but us.”

There are negatives to correct and – despite Gibson’s somber tone afterward – positives to build upon. But looking back at the pass interference and a singular crucial moment, the biggest of questions will be what might have been.

Home forums Phantom Pass Interference Haunts WVU Defense

This topic contains 8 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by  Allen .

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
  • #33241

    Phantom Pass Interference Haunts WVU Defense MORGANTOWN, W.Va. – There’s no excusing portions of West Virginia’s defensive play. The Mountaineers had
    [See the full post at: Phantom Pass Interference Haunts WVU Defense]


    Officiating at the college level – at least what I’ve seen in the B12 this season – does not have the quality needed at the D1 level. People will say that 1 play doesn’t decide a football game, probably true, but a bad call can certainly influence the h3ll out of the game.


    That was a bad call, but WV got beat all day in the trenches.  Can’t win when your lines get pushed around.


    I don’t know what play people were watching but that was clearly pass interference. Because once again, a WVU defensive back did not turn around to play the ball. If he does he probably picks it off. You can’t face guard a receiver and that’s what Bailey did. He put up both his arms and ran right into the receiver clearly making contact. It was an obvious call.


    From what I saw I agree with Papillon.  When are our DBs going to learn that you have to look back and at least look as if you’re making a play for the ball?  On the other hand, I’ve also seen officials often ignore plays like the one  that was called for PI against us.  Some consistency would be appreciated.  Anyway, the game was obviously lost in the trenches.  If we can’t get our running game going, we won’t any more games this season.


    When I saw it the first time I thought it was a bad call.  Seeing the subsequent different angle replays I agreed with the call.   Reluctantly.


    Agreed on lost in the trenches. I didn’t think there was remotely enough contact, though there’s no question Bailey didn’t get the head around. It’s a lot harder to play DB than it once was with back shoulder throws, consistent challenges vertically, mesh and rub routes, etc.


    Turn that head too early and look and that WR gains a step and boom, burned. It’s very difficult to play defense in today’s game without four major d-linemen.


    I agree.  Pass interference is called so often in the college game, it’s getting to be very difficult to play pass defense.  I think the advantage is very much with the offense now; I wish officials would allow the DBs and WRs to battle it out and only throw a flag for really obvious infractions.  In other words, I think the call against us was technically PI, but I don’t think it should be.  Good Lord, it’s just becoming too hard to play pass defense in the college game.  It might be a bad analogy, but I think some incidental contact when playing pass defense is like incidental contact in college basketball.  You could call a foul on virtually every possession in college basketball, but in so doing you’d ruin the game.  I’m a big believer in letting the athletes, not the officials, decide the outcome.  If a DB obviously hits a guy early or is grabbing the WR or holding his jersey, throw the flag.  Otherwise, let them play.  The DB is usually at a distinct disadvantage, so give him the benefit of the doubt.  OK, that’s the end of my homily.

    On the bright side, we’re going to beat Iowa State.  It’ll be a battle, but I think our men feel a little embarrassed about the OK State game, and they’re going to play like guys who have something to prove this Saturday.  I just don’t see us losing two in a row at home, and I have a feeling the offensive line in particular has something to prove after Saturday’s poor performance.  We’ll see.


    Pass interference is most often called when a defensive player makes contact with an offensive player before the pass arrives, and that contact inhibits the offensive player from catching the pass. Examples of this contact can be a defensive player who trips up a wide receiver, grabs the arm of a player so that they cannot catch the ball, or a defender who makes contact with an offensive player without looking for the location of the ball.

    PI is not called on defender if he doesn’t turn around. It is called if he contact with WR. A defender can tip the ball away even if he doesn’t turn around. Turning around doesn’t guarantee an interception nor does it guarantee that PI will not be called.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Home forums Phantom Pass Interference Haunts WVU Defense