WVU’s NFL Draft Candidates: When Should They Go? And Where Will They?

WVU’s NFL Draft Candidates: When Should They Go? And Where Will They?

The only thing sure about the NFL Draft is that many of the selections, and the order in which they go off the board, will not match up to the collegiate performances of the players involved. There are many reasons for this, including the dissonance between collegiate and NFL systems, level of competition, workout performances, lingering injuries and health status.

West Virginia linebacker David Long (11) sacks Kansas quarterback Peyton Bender (9)

Perhaps looming even larger are evaluations of players, which often ignore their performances in actual games, and instead focus on measurables or the number of times a player performed an esoteric drill. In other words, things that have some football-like action in them, but don’t resemble games much at all.

Finally, there’s the view of the league as a whole on any particular player. If they all think he’s a fifth-rounder, no one is likely to draft him where he should have gone, because they will be able to get him later with a lower pick. Occasionally, there are outliers (see Bruce Irvin), but sometimes players get tagged and fall into slots that don’t reflect their true value.

What if scouts and player personnel directors put more emphasis on what those prospects did on the playing field,  including a look at leadership and off-field behaviors, rather than the number of bench press reps or their Wonderlic scores? That’s the drill here – where would West Virginia’s candidates for spots in the league rate based on what they’ve done, rather than projections which might as well have been made by crystal ball and Ouija board? Here’s one man’s look at their performance round – where they might have been drafted based on what they’ve done – along with a guess as to where they might actually be picked.

QB Will Grier     Performance Round: Second     Predicted Round: Third

Grier’s numbers should put him no worse than third overall among quarterbacks, but he probably won’t go until at least four other QBs are selected. Much of this positioning is based on runs at the position – if every team that needs a QB takes one with its first pick, he could go higher. Some of the issues with him are realistic, including ball security and a tendency to force a throw here or there, but there just shouldn’t be much arguing with the numbers he put up. Also, labeling him a “system” quarterback is simply a lazy evaluation. If the system were the reason for success, why isn’t every college team running it? Answer: Because there aren’t a lot of quarterbacks like Grier out there.

LB David Long      Performance Round: Third     Predicted Round: Fourth

Long gets dinged by some projections for too much freelancing. Guess what? That’s what he was coached to do at WVU, especially in his last season, when the positions around him were decimated by injuries. He also takes knocks for being undersized. Anybody remember Sam Mills or Dat Nguyen? Sure, he can’t be a mike backer, but as an outside guy in a 3-4 or a will in a 4-3? Nobody will outwork or outhustle him, and he’ll also be a special teams stalwart while being 100 percent coachable.

TE Trevon Wesco     Performance Round: Third     Predicted Round: Fifth

Some of the “analysis” on Wesco blows my mind. There are notes about him having to improve his ball catching and work on his blocking technique. Did any of these guys actually watch film? Wesco is not as fleet of foot as a few other tight ends in the draft, and probably needs to improve his route running a bit. But there’s no one that puts all of the old- and new-school tight end skills together better than he does. Hhe had a couple of spectacular catches this year while not dropping catchable passes. Perhaps a team will ignore the conventional ratings and select him where he should be picked.

WR Gary Jennings     Performance Round: Third     Predicted Round: Fourth

Jennings has proven performance, catches the ball well and can play either slot or the outside. He surprised some evaluators with the speed he showed at the Senior Bowl and at the Combine, even though numerous clips existed of him running by and away from defenders on deep routes at WVU.  That should be enough to get him at least to the round in which he belongs in this draft. Again, as at quarterback, how quickly those rated in front of him are taken will have a proportionate effect on where he goes.

WR David Sills     Performance Round: Fourth     Predicted Round: Fourth

While performance on the field is high on our criteria list here, there are some stats that are overrated. Touchdowns are one of them, as those numbers can be bolstered based on the strengths of the offensive system in use by a player’s team. At WVU over the last two years, power blocking in short yardage situations wasn’t a strength, leading to more passes in the red zone, which helped Sills bolster his touchdown receptions. That’s not Sills’ fault, but it’s tough to give a huge edge to a receiver based on TD catches, unless he had a massive stat line of numerous long-distance scoring catches. Sills also had some struggles with drops during his senior year, but maybe those won’t have a big effect on a team looking for a red zone receiving weapon.

OL Yodny Cajuste    Performance Round: Third     Predicted Round: Fourth

How much will Cajuste’s injury history affect his draft status? Reported surgery to repair a quad muscle injury at the end of March is just the latest of a series of medical issues that knocked him out of West Virginia’s final regular season game and caused him to miss WVU’s bowl game, the Senior Bowl and any meaningful participation at the NFL Combine. His slot is the toughest to judge – based on assessments of potential, he could be in the third round. He was West Virginia’s third-best offensive lineman in 2018 in my view, but that’s not one that is shared by many evaluators – it’s the injury status that will likely hold sway.

Home forums WVU’s NFL Draft Candidates: When Should They Go? And Where Will They?

  • This topic has 2 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated by Kevin KinderKevin Kinder.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
  • #89686

    WVU’s NFL Draft Candidates: When Should They Go? And Where Will They? The only thing sure about the NFL Draft is that many of the selections, and the
    [See the full post at: WVU’s NFL Draft Candidates: When Should They Go? And Where Will They?]


    No surprise for us tonight…  not even a sniff. Watching with a WV buddy who was really waiting for Grier at 32.

    While i think the pats would take Grier before Lock I never saw them reaching for either. Neither project that well or hold a high spot on other team’s boards (Lock moreso than Grier).

    Both probably go early tomorrow and would be shocked to see Grier to Pats with late second round pick (unless they see themselves as his only real suitor and they let him fall farther).

    Bottom line – I think a bunch of teams get really good value in a a handful of WVU guys… Jennings, Sills, Long, Grier and Wesco.

    Im not sold on Cajuste as a producer at any level.


    Grier’s chance to go in the first round probably hinged on Lock getting taken in the mid-round, and setting up a mini-run on QBs. Agreed that today should be a much better day for WVU.


Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Home forums WVU’s NFL Draft Candidates: When Should They Go? And Where Will They?